The Sweet Truth: Unexpected Findings from Sugar-Free Consumers

The Sweet Truth: Unexpected Findings from Sugar-Free Consumers

In a world obsessed with instant gratification, consumers are increasingly trading sugary highs for lasting energy and well-being. The once-beloved sweet treat is now under scrutiny as people become more aware of sugar's hidden health consequences. This shift is driving a surge in demand for sugar-free and low-sugar alternatives that promise both taste and vitality.

The Sugar Awakening 

With growing knowledge about sugar's impact, consumers are now looking beyond simple calorie counting. The American Heart Association recommends no more than 9 teaspoons of added sugar per day for men and 6 teaspoons for women. Yet, the average American consumes about 77 grams of added sugar per day, equivalent to nearly 19 teaspoons. This stark contrast has fueled a growing awareness of the need for moderation and healthier alternatives.

However, while the desire for sugar reduction is evident, our research at Brightfield Group reveals a surprising trend: negative consumer sentiment surrounding sugar-free and low-sugar products.

One thing that stands out is a trend of negative sentiment around sugar reduction. Social media seems to focus more on what's being taken away ("low sugar," "no sugar") instead of highlighting the positive benefits.

Consumer Negativity Towards Sugar Reduction:

  • Focus on "Removal" vs. "Benefit": Social media posts promoting sugar-free products often highlight what's missing ("low sugar," "no sugar") rather than positive attributes. Imagine a trip ad focusing on "no bad weather" instead of sunny beaches!
  • "Guilt-Free" Wording: Many posts use terms like "guilt-free indulgence" suggesting consumers associate sugar-free with compromise.
  • Lack of Enthusiastic Language: Descriptions lack excitement compared to other products, focusing on technical details like protein grams instead of taste or benefits.

Additional Insights:

  • Gender/Generation: Social listening shows "sugar-free" and "low-sugar" over-index for women and Millennials/Gen-X, who tend towards removal claims. Men and Gen-Z lean more towards "high protein" and "keto" claims.
  • Sugar-Free vs. Keto Sentiment: Interestingly, sentiment analysis shows a higher proportion of negative posts for sugar-free compared to keto. This suggests "keto" might be perceived more positively as a "what it is" approach, focusing on benefits like weight loss or energy. Metrics:
  • Sentiment: Sugar-free posts have nearly double the negativity compared to keto posts (e.g., sugar-free: 90% positive, 10% negative; keto: 95% positive, 5% negative).

The evidence suggests consumers might view sugar reduction as a necessary evil rather than a positive choice. The language used reinforces this by emphasizing what's missing, focusing on guilt-free indulgence, and lacking enthusiastic descriptions.

New call-to-action

Beyond Sweetness: Health and Sugar

The link between excessive sugar consumption and chronic diseases is becoming increasingly evident. Type 2 diabetes, obesity, heart disease, and even certain types of cancer have been associated with high sugar intake. As consumers become more proactive about their health, they are seeking ways to reduce their sugar consumption and mitigate these risks.

Sugar-Free and Health Conditions 

Our research highlights the increasing adoption of sugar-free options among individuals managing health conditions like diabetes and PCOS. Growing awareness of the link between sugar intake and hormonal balance is fueling this interest. PCOS, in particular, can lead to insulin resistance and blood sugar imbalances, making sugar reduction crucial in managing this condition. Additionally, consumers with behavioral conditions such as ADHD or anxiety are experimenting with sugar reduction as a part of a holistic approach to support wellness. Ingredient Importance in Food and Bev

Who's Cutting Back? 

Our research reveals that health-conscious individuals of all ages are actively seeking sugar-free alternatives. The Millennials/Gen-X generations  demonstrate a strong interest, reflecting their focus on proactive wellness. With innovative products like Joydays baked goods and Perfy sodas entering the market, consumers have more delicious and satisfying options than ever before. 

Low Sugar Demographic Analysis-1


Decoding the Sugar-Free Landscape: Tips for Consumers 

Navigating the world of sugar substitutes can be overwhelming. With a plethora of options available, it's essential to make informed choices. Some popular alternatives include stevia, monk fruit, erythritol, and allulose. While these sweeteners offer sugar-free options, it's crucial to consider their potential impact on blood sugar levels and overall health. Here are some tips for making informed choices: 

  • Read Labels Carefully: Not all sugar substitutes are created equal. Look for naturally derived options and avoid artificial sweeteners that might have their own drawbacks. 
  • Experiment and Find Your Favorites: Explore different sugar-free products and discover flavors you genuinely enjoy. This is key to sustainable change. 
  • Don't Neglect Whole Foods: Sugar-free products can be helpful, but don't forget the power of whole foods for balanced energy levels and overall health.

Opportunities for Brands 

The shift towards sugar-free alternatives presents a significant opportunity for brands to innovate and meet the evolving demands of consumers. By developing delicious and satisfying sugar-free products, brands can tap into this growing market and build customer loyalty.



The sugar-free movement is more than just a passing trend; it represents a fundamental shift in consumer priorities. As awareness of sugar's health implications continues to grow, the demand for healthier alternatives will only increase. By understanding the drivers behind this trend and catering to the evolving needs of consumers, brands can position themselves for success in the sugar-free landscape.

Watch our latest webinar


Updated: 06/11/2024